| common drop | uncommon drop | rare drop | very rare drop |
|---|---|---|---|
| fallen’s goo (*required!) | |||
| jystyr’s goo (*required!) | |||
| empty vial (*required!) | |||
| werewolf fur | |||
| sugar | |||
| spice | |||
| cat whisker | |||
| magic powder | broken potion | ||
| candy snake | |||
| shaped erasers | |||
| clown makeup | |||
| pumpkin seed | |||
| plastic halo | |||
| cat tail | |||
| plastic horns | |||
| vampire’s fang | carved pumpkin | ||
| loose screw | |||
| cat headband | |||
| chicken foot | |||
| lightbulb | |||
| haunted doll | black bottle | ||
| ectoplasm | |||
| doll head | |||
| plastic arachnid |
special prize, with a drop rate between uncommon-rare: jystyr’s bell (*not a required ingredient!)
items marked as (*required!) are needed in the cauldron (shop), but you only need 1 per creation!